Logo

OEM parts incorrect?

ianmoore

Member
Hello,

I've been having a heck of a time rebuilding the water pump on my 1985 7.5 HP.

I've been using the Marineengine parts list that aligns with the serial number on my engine, but seem to be running into some incongruence with the parts.
I ordered the water pump rebuild kit
18-3446 - Water Pump Kit 46-70941A3
and the impeller key
28-8M0032835 - Key
ADKq_NYIVCor6tl1FEsiU6M2lAv60JjoAS4N7RdeIV9XEBEEGqigGoG2wqCS7IKkUV5ZQ9Tz1X2eXPzF5BqD5TIDJpFfH3IzGEjLYGHnqRlHFArzww9Lib8vYw=s0-d-e1-ft

I've attached a photo and you can see that they impeller key(packaged in OEM bag with correct part number) is much too big for the groove on the impeller.

I also had a similar issue with the shift shaft oil seal not fitting into the bushing. The bushing was in the motor when I bought it, so I can't 100% be sure that it was the correct bushing, but it was a working part when I disassembled it, so I would assume it was. I warped the bushing trying to get the seal to sit(my bad--lack of experience) but had assumed the part was correct, and was following the instructions on the service manual.

Has anyone had this experience with OEM parts bought from Marinengine?

Ian
IMG_2737.jpeg
 
Hello,

I've been having a heck of a time rebuilding the water pump on my 1985 7.5 HP.

I've been using the Marineengine parts list that aligns with the serial number on my engine, but seem to be running into some incongruence with the parts.
I ordered the water pump rebuild kit
18-3446 - Water Pump Kit 46-70941A3
and the impeller key
28-8M0032835 - Key
ADKq_NYIVCor6tl1FEsiU6M2lAv60JjoAS4N7RdeIV9XEBEEGqigGoG2wqCS7IKkUV5ZQ9Tz1X2eXPzF5BqD5TIDJpFfH3IzGEjLYGHnqRlHFArzww9Lib8vYw=s0-d-e1-ft

I've attached a photo and you can see that they impeller key(packaged in OEM bag with correct part number) is much too big for the groove on the impeller.

I also had a similar issue with the shift shaft oil seal not fitting into the bushing. The bushing was in the motor when I bought it, so I can't 100% be sure that it was the correct bushing, but it was a working part when I disassembled it, so I would assume it was. I warped the bushing trying to get the seal to sit(my bad--lack of experience) but had assumed the part was correct, and was following the instructions on the service manual.

Has anyone had this experience with OEM parts bought from Marinengine?

IanView attachment 32962

Sierra parts aren't OEM.

If the bag was sealed, call the seller and have them send a replacement. The old key can be reused, BTW- it's not a consumable part.
 
Sierra parts aren't OEM.

If the bag was sealed, call the seller and have them send a replacement. The old key can be reused, BTW- it's not a consumable part.
I have an email into Marineengine to check on this. Both of the parts that I got were Mercury/Quicksilver parts.
I would have reused the key, but lost it when I was working on the rebuild.
 
I have an email into Marineengine to check on this. Both of the parts that I got were Mercury/Quicksilver parts.
I would have reused the key, but lost it when I was working on the rebuild.
OK, I saw the 18-3446 and thought you bought a Sierra kit.

Look on the drive shaft- the key likes to stick to that. Use a dab of grease to keep it in place while you slide the impeller on.
 
OK, I saw the 18-3446 and thought you bought a Sierra kit.

Look on the drive shaft- the key likes to stick to that. Use a dab of grease to keep it in place while you slide the impeller on.
I spent a good 30 minutes trying to get the impeller over the key! I started that by putting some grease on the plane where it mounts.
It sure seems like the key is incorrect. If you look at the picture, you can see that the size of the key is significantly bigger than the slot in the impeller, and I tried everything I could to get it over the key and into the pump base.
 
Pretty annoying. I'm going back and forth with the marinenengine folks. I sent them a pic(the same one I posted here) that clearly shows that the key is incorrect for the impeller. Just went on Amazon and bought a cheap impeller that came with a key just so I can get the impeller in and finish my water pump. I don't know what the deal is, but here is the Chinese one, where at least in the image, the key seems to fit the impeller
1719325222025.png
 
Where did you lose the original key? They have a nasty habit of falling down inside the water passage of the impeller cup and hiding in that recess. Also there were two different driveshaft diameters; .438" and .456" depending on year. I would assume the keys were the same.
 
Where did you lose the original key? They have a nasty habit of falling down inside the water passage of the impeller cup and hiding in that recess. Also there were two different driveshaft diameters; .438" and .456" depending on year. I would assume the keys were the same.
I'm pretty sure that's where it ended up. My "working" area for the boat is over a gravel driveway, so it is possible it fell there. In either case, I spent a quantifiable amount of time trying to find it and decided, since I had to get a couple of other parts, that I would just get another key. Hence the frustration with the new key not fitting!
I don't think the driveshaft diameter should make a huge difference for the key(I'm going to measure as I didn't know that) as the issue is simply that the key itself doesn't fit the groove in the impeller. I'm definitely not a boat mechanic, but I've changed enough impellers in my life to know how they are supposed to sit.
 
I spent a good 30 minutes trying to get the impeller over the key! I started that by putting some grease on the plane where it mounts.
It sure seems like the key is incorrect. If you look at the picture, you can see that the size of the key is significantly bigger than the slot in the impeller, and I tried everything I could to get it over the key and into the pump base.
The key in the photo isn't even close. Looks like the one for the Alpha Gen 2 impeller. The older Alpha has a smaller, plastic water pump cover with a smaller impeller and the Gen 2 has a metal cover and larger impeller.
 
The key in the photo isn't even close. Looks like the one for the Alpha Gen 2 impeller. The older Alpha has a smaller, plastic water pump cover with a smaller impeller and the Gen 2 has a metal cover and larger impeller.
I know! Thanks for validating this rant! The crazy thing is that it was packaged in a quicksilver bag with the correct part number, at least according to the marineengine serial number parts list. I've used these parts references for years with my motors and never had an issue. When I first rebuilt my water pump, I got a cheap Chinese one. There was no lower oil seal on that water pump, and the seal I ordered didn't fit, so I had to use the old pump base. The key and impeller fit perfectly, but when I barrel-tested the water pump, it didn't seem to have enough push, so I decided to start over and "do it right." I guess that's why its so frustrating. I expect this stuff with the cheap Chinese stuff. If you want to go on the cheap, you make do with what it is, but when you are paying premium money for these OEM parts you are doing this with confidence that they truly are the correct parts and you shouldn't have to deal with this BS.
 
I know! Thanks for validating this rant! The crazy thing is that it was packaged in a quicksilver bag with the correct part number, at least according to the marineengine serial number parts list. I've used these parts references for years with my motors and never had an issue. When I first rebuilt my water pump, I got a cheap Chinese one. There was no lower oil seal on that water pump, and the seal I ordered didn't fit, so I had to use the old pump base. The key and impeller fit perfectly, but when I barrel-tested the water pump, it didn't seem to have enough push, so I decided to start over and "do it right." I guess that's why its so frustrating. I expect this stuff with the cheap Chinese stuff. If you want to go on the cheap, you make do with what it is, but when you are paying premium money for these OEM parts you are doing this with confidence that they truly are the correct parts and you shouldn't have to deal with this BS.
I usually try to buy locally and have bought some parts from Amazon but I won't use off the wall Chinese branded stuff. I have used Sierra's (not part of Dometic) tech support that I feel it's only right to use their products when they'll do the job, although I did find that my '84 boat needed the Quicksilver housing because the Sierra didn't fit and the plastic isn't as durable. To be fair, I have installed a few hundred Sierra water pump kits and their parts work well.

Are you using the Mercury EPC to look for part numbers? Any that have a + next to the text and a link are the new part numbers, superceded from the original.
 
I usually try to buy locally and have bought some parts from Amazon but I won't use off the wall Chinese branded stuff. I have used Sierra's (not part of Dometic) tech support that I feel it's only right to use their products when they'll do the job, although I did find that my '84 boat needed the Quicksilver housing because the Sierra didn't fit and the plastic isn't as durable. To be fair, I have installed a few hundred Sierra water pump kits and their parts work well.

Are you using the Mercury EPC to look for part numbers? Any that have a + next to the text and a link are the new part numbers, superceded from the original.
I actually did not know about the Mercury EPC. I have been using marinengine for the serial number cross reference. I did just check it out, but when I entered my serial number "A172298" nothing comes up
 
I actually did not know about the Mercury EPC. I have been using marinengine for the serial number cross reference. I did just check it out, but when I entered my serial number "A172298" nothing comes up
I live on an island in the Seattle area, and when I can, I use Seaway marine. Its a bit of a drive to get there. Used to be in West Seattle, which is right across the water, but real estate costs made them move pretty far up north
 

@jimn Curious, while on the subject, if you have any knowledge on the oilseal that sits on top of the bushing with the shiftshaft--26-30696 (#44 on pic below)​

The service manual says to mount it with the "lip facing the outside", which i take to mean the lip facing upwards towards the engine. I don't know much about oil seals, but my intuition tells me the lip should be down as it seems it would make a better seal for the oil.
1719345299726.png

​

 
Just to close the loop on this initial issue. It turns out that all the mercury keys they had(individually wrapped and marked from quicksilver) were incorrect! Making me wonder if the oil seal they sent was the wrong one too! I couldn't get it to sit in the bushing
 
My experience is that seal is a very light tap fit to install, I have actually pushed them in with my fingers. I always blue lock tite them in anyway as I do all seals. Also replace the shift shaft bushing oring. Make sure hold the shift shaft down while removing the bushing so you don't lift the shift shaft out of the cam or you'll need to disassemble the lower propshaft assembly to re-align the cam into the shiftshaft.
 
The service manual actually says to use red loctite. Does it make sense to put the seal with lip facing up?
Unfortunately the shiftshaft is sloe and out of the cam. I actually got it back in once without having to dissasemble the propshaft, but that was half luck and unfortunately when I move it, it came back out. I had it marked and everything for reassembly!
 
You want to keep the water out so the lip faces up, I was taught 50 years ago (as a shop rat )at the Evinrude dealership to use blue on all seals and it has always worked. Just went out to the shop, in stock gearcases, 1973 7.5 seal lip up, 1967 3.9 seal lip up, 1968 20 seal lip up.
 
You want to keep the water out so the lip faces up, I was taught 50 years ago (as a shop rat )at the Evinrude dealership to use blue on all seals and it has always worked. Just went out to the shop, in stock gearcases, 1973 7.5 seal lip up, 1967 3.9 seal lip up, 1968 20 seal lip up.
Thank you so much. I don't know why, as a total rookie in this world, I would doubt the service manual, but wanted to make sure.
Awaiting parts to stop lower oil leak through shift shaft, and then seeing if the new water pump solves my cooling problem. I'm a little concerned that its not the pump, but I guess good news is that the lower unit should be in decent shape...Here's hoping i can get the shift shaft back in without taking the whole thing apart
 
It's really not a big deal if you need to anyway. Done it many times. Help is here if you need it. Hardest part of the job is getting the spanner nut loose. Atfer that not much.
 
It's really not a big deal if you need to anyway. Done it many times. Help is here if you need it. Hardest part of the job is getting the spanner nut loose. Atfer that not much.
I really appreciate that. I rebuilt a lower unit on a 1955 Evinrude and had to improvise a bit.
Where I anticipate needing some help is next steps if I'm still not getting water to the engine block.
I tried all the unclogging tricks with compressed air, water, etc...Even though my first water pump rebuild(with a cheap chinese water pump) probably wasn't the greatest, it was pumping water ok, but when I hooked it up and tried to run it, was only getting steam through engine and a small drip of water. The engine, other than over heating, seemed to be running normally
One thing of note, maybe nothing, but when I ran compressed air from the bottom through the water tube I got a faint bit of air through the water valve at the engine block, but when I ran it into the engine block it made a loud "wooshing" sound coming from the midsection and i didn't feel much pressure from the water tube below. My total "rookie" thought with this was maybe there was a leak somewhere that was preventing the water from having enough pressure to get through the engine block...So, If i put lower unit back together and water pump is working as it should, but i'm still not getting water through engine, what your next step be?
 
To be clear, You can chuck an electric drill to the top of the driveshaft spline, submerge the gearcase in a bucket, spin the drill (clockwise) and you see water coming out of the waterpump outlet to confirm the pump is pumping, did you do that?
 
I did. When I first rebuilt the water pump with a cheap chinese one, I had to use the existing water pump base as I couldn’t get the lower water pump seal to fit. I did the bucket/drill test and it did pump water, but I was told that the spec was minimum 6-8” and it was less than that. I decided at that point to rebuild pump using mercury parts and see if that gave me better water pressure
 
I've never had one shoot 6-8 inches in that test, I've never seen that "spec" next would be to adapt a garden hose to the watertube and see if you can get water to circulate through the block, a piece of 1/4 or 5/16 ID fuel hose over the water tube works fine with some electrical tape and adapt to a normal garden house and just crack the spigot. Do you get water through the block?
 
Well, as I said earlier, the good news is I’ll have a totally new Mercury spec water pump. I’ve definitely wasted my money on worse things.
I actually have a flush fitting for that motor that goes over a garden hose into a port(I think 5/16”) so I’ll give that a try today.
 
The flush fitting will test for water circulating through the block, what is will not test is if the plastic washer that sits on top of the water tube / grommet, that is sandwiched between the powerhead and mid section has beed distorted or melted from overheat that would restrict waterflow coming through the water tube into the block. The powerhead needs to be removed to validate the condition.
 
The color of the thread locker is less important than whether it's specified for temporary or permanent use.
 

@jimn Curious, while on the subject, if you have any knowledge on the oilseal that sits on top of the bushing with the shiftshaft--26-30696 (#44 on pic below)​

The service manual says to mount it with the "lip facing the outside", which i take to mean the lip facing upwards towards the engine. I don't know much about oil seals, but my intuition tells me the lip should be down as it seems it would make a better seal for the oil.
View attachment 32978

​

Follow the manual.
 
Back
Top