Logo

Bilge pump replacement time

kirkll

Regular Contributor
What do you guys recommend for a replacement bilge pump. There are so many out there the choices are overwhelming. I kind of like the idea of having a float switch that can be left in automatic mode when I’ve got the boat moored and fishing in serious rain conditions.

1990 19’ executive Cuddy II. Alpha one mercruiser . Thanks, Kirk
 
the biggest you can fit and afford, if you install a float switch, that is the automatic system when correctly wired to the battery
 
If you do the research on bilge pump switches you'll buy a Water Witch.
I recommend that you use a two pump system. You want one for nuisance water like rain (small pump), and one for water removal in case of emergency (huge-ass pump). These should be on independent circuits. Keep in mind that having a bilge pump set up to be automatic doesn't mean that you can just leave the boat and forget about it. Lotsa things can go wrong...float switch stuck open, battery gone flat, etc.
 
the biggest you can fit and afford, if you install a float switch, that is the automatic system when correctly wired to the battery


Yes, the float switch (when powered via an "Un-Interruptible" power supply) will make the bilge pump Automatic.


DO NOT use a Manual/OFF/Auto helm switch.

Mount your float switch at a higher elevation than the pump's lowest draw-down capability.
 
If you do the research on bilge pump switches you'll buy a Water Witch.
I recommend that you use a two pump system. You want one for nuisance water like rain (small pump), and one for water removal in case of emergency (huge-ass pump). These should be on independent circuits. Keep in mind that having a bilge pump set up to be automatic doesn't mean that you can just leave the boat and forget about it. Lotsa things can go wrong...float switch stuck open, battery gone flat, etc.

Thanks a bunch....

I thought about using a two pump system just like you described actually. set one on a manual switch and one with a float. But what would you call a "Huge-ass pump" fore emergency? how many gallons per hour. i think that's how they rate them.

I've had experience on my smaller boats with cheap float switches getting stuck open and draining the battery. That's one of the reasons i was asking for recommendations here. This boat is serious heavy by comparison to my little aluminum boat, and i want to cover me arse. i fish some pretty foul weather for salmon in the fall and moor my boat short term. i check on it daily while its moored. i've seen it rain inches over night on the Oregon coast. i also have a twin battery switch set up to keep a bilge pump with a float isolated to one battery over night. Kirk
 
On my 24 i had a 1500 and a 1800 in the engine conpartment, best location is above the water line stbd side . You can see any discharge
 
ok.... now running two pumps do you need separate discharge lines through the hull? or can you put a Y in the line?

With a Y in the line and two pumps running you could use it as a fire hose!;)
 
ok.... now running two pumps do you need separate discharge lines through the hull? or can you put a Y in the line?

With a Y in the line and two pumps running you could use it as a fire hose!;)


Each bilge pump should have it's own discharge line and it's own thru-hull fitting.


As for your question in post #5 re; pump volume........ keep in mind that the main bilge pump's most important duty will occur during an emergency.
This is why we size them larger than need be for non-emergency use.


Chose your brand and GPH;

shopping


shopping





.

 
I would imagine having a large emergency bilge pump would be mandatory taking the boat in to blue water, or even crossing the bar for that matter.

But our primary use for this craft will be fishing big lakes, rivers, and in the bay. I do not have a lot of hours logged as a captain outside the jaws of the bays, and do not plan to do much of that, if at all. I will avoid he Columbia River bar completely..... So I don’t really think an emergency pump it necessary at this time..... but if I had it , I might be tempted to slip out in to salt water on calm days for some bottom fishing..... thanks again for the info .... Kirk
 
I would imagine having a large emergency bilge pump would be mandatory taking the boat in to blue water, or even crossing the bar for that matter.

But our primary use for this craft will be fishing big lakes, rivers, and in the bay. I do not have a lot of hours logged as a captain outside the jaws of the bays, and do not plan to do much of that, if at all. I will avoid he Columbia River bar completely..... So I don’t really think an emergency pump it necessary at this time..... but if I had it , I might be tempted to slip out in to salt water on calm days for some bottom fishing..... thanks again for the info .... Kirk

If you were to encounter a leak, and lets say a large leak, it won't matter if you are inland or out in the ocean, or if you are out there for only 10 minutes or for 10 hours.
A large leak can sink a boat in short order.


Think of it this way.
If your trip to/from work each day is only 4 miles, do you not need to carry a spare tire?
Or, if your trip to/from work each day is 50 miles, would you be more inclined to carry a spare tire?

I would want a spare tire no mater how far I traveled.

 
I work in a local big box marine store, and have owned and maintained boats since 1964... That said, of last several years I have seen a rash of failures on pumps with INTERNAL automatic switches, so much so that not only do I not use them on my boat and the ones I'm responsible for maintaining, but to my customers as well. I have found that the float switches in cages ( not open ones) are the least trouble. The only ever require maintenance in boats with "dirty bilges"... the combo of water and engine oil drips forms a crud that can cause the float to stick... Keeping your bilge clean prevents this, a splash of marine friendly soapy water fixes it.
My 23 ft old school (non self bailing decks) cuddy cabin deep V has a 500 gph and a 2000 gph per o2batsea ( post #3). Ditto on everything he says. The only additional input.... my 500 gph with float switch is connected directly to my #2 battery which is a dual purpose battery, while my 2000 gph is connected to my #1 start battery. Connected to, means directly at the battery with fuses.

The pumps sit on the bottom of the bilge, while the float switches are mounted on custom aluminum brackets that position the 500 gph switch as low as possible, with the 2000 gph pump's switch set an inch higher.

My boat was tied up in a slip with all canvas removed in a lagoon off the mouth of the Toms River (north bank) less than two miles south from "Ground Zero" in Hurricane Sandy. The #2 battery was dead, while the #1 battery while partially discharged had no problem starting my 5.7 260HP MIE. Boat sat at its normal water line. I've used this system for over 50 years and have had a boat in the water for every named hurricane and tropical storm ( and endless Nor'Easters) during this period.
 
If you moor a boat and leave it unattended, your MBSS is going to most likely be turned off.
(MBSS = main battery selector switch)

This is why we power a main bilge pump float switch from an Un-Interruptible power source... (I.E., either directly to the largest Amp Hour battery bank, or better yet to the correct terminal at the rear of the MBSS for that same battery bank.)

Now you can leave the boat with the MBSS turned off, yet the float switch still has available power to it.



The reason for mounting the float switch at a slightly higher elevation than the pump's lowest draw-down ability, is so that the float switch contacts can return to "open".
If the float switch is mounted too low, the pump may not draw down the water enough to allow the float switch to "open", causing the pump to continue operating, therefor draining the battery bank.




.
 
Hey guys, I appreciate the voice of experience and your suggestions. I'm definitely into spare tires....

This is a beautiful old boat i'm getting ready for use, and i want to set things up right, and make it safe as possible. This being my first REAL boat, I've got a ton of things to learn. It's in really good shape, but i do not have a maintenance log for it. The last owner didn't keep one. So i'm going through everything one step at a time and getting a feel for the old girl and getting my log book set up. I've had quite a few smaller open fishing boats so i'm no rookie in that regard. But this bigger boat with an inboard motor is going to require much more maintenance, and i'm not assuming any of it is current.

I've only had it in the water a couple times now, and I believe i have a slow leak coming in somewhere. Last outing we stayed out for about 6-7 hours and i had almost 4" of water in the lower section of the bilge. That's when i found out my bilge pump was making noise but not pumping water. It rained that same night and i only had the aft section partially covered. So part of that bilge water could have been rain coming off the tarp.

a couple more questions on bilge pumps and i'll move on.....

I researched The Water Witch. This is a sensor switch i believe. I see the advantage of no moving parts, but how do you test a sensor like this. With a mechanical float it's pretty easy to check out whether it's working properly. Being kind of old school, i'm Leary of magic electronic stuff......

Same question on a high water alarm set up. If the water level gets high and the pumps malfunctions, it would be good to know. So what are your opinions on having an alarm set up too? This just happened too me with one bilge pump that puked.

Once again, i appreciate your opinions and help. Kirk
 
The Water Witch isn't really "testable" in the sense that you can push on a mechanical thing and bypass it to see if the pump comes on. All I can say is that it works. I was also leery at first so I tested it myself...dunked it in gas, checked it in water...worked. Dunked it in diesel, checked it in water...worked. Dunked it in oil, tested in water...worked. I can't see HOW it works but it does. I would and do bet my boat on it. Again it's all about your comfort level with electronics. Do you have a cell phone? Do you worry every time you pull it out to use it that it will fail? Yeh. It's like that.
Also, the secondary "emergency" pump is only going to buy time if the boat is going down. It'll poop out the battery pretty quick if it's doing yeoman's duty and pumping at max. Let's hope you never ever have to use it! But it can give you a little time to get the raft out, gather up the ditch bag and get off safely.
Rule or Johnson non auto 4000gph. Two if you can fit em. These pumps are rated at optimal conditions, which you never achieve in the real world. Count on about half of a pump's rating.
One of the things that reduce efficiency is the convoluted hose that's sold as bilge pump hose. Don't use that. You want a smooth hose with as little restriction as possible. Your thru hull is gonna be another choke point. Get the biggest outlet that will work.
 
"Also, the secondary "emergency" pump is only going to buy time if the boat is going down. It'll poop out the battery pretty quick if it's doing yeoman's duty and pumping at max. Let's hope you never ever have to use it! But it can give you a little time to get the raft out, gather up the ditch bag and get off safely."

There is one other scenario... Had an event on my first boat where we took on a fair amount of water... both pumps kicked in, but since the big pump was hooked up the to start battery and the engine was still running, we were able to get home safely...
 
If you have a two battery system, and the engine running, wouldn’t both batteries be getting juice from the alternator?
i have a two battery system, but haven’t ran it enough to know how well the charging system works.

i assumed (and I hate that word) if you were running the boat and had the selector on “all” , it would charge both batteries....???
 
Oh gawd let's not get into that discussion with Post Count Rick lurking.

Really tho, with a 65 amp alternator it won't be able to keep up with the draw on the batteries. Even at wide open, the alternator isn't spinning at its "rated" output which is somewhere around 15 thousand rpm.
 
Last edited:
Oh gawd let's not get into that discussion with Post Count Rick lurking.

Really tho, with a 65 amp alternator it won't be able to keep up with the draw on the batteries. Even at wide open, the alternator isn't spinning at its "rated" output which is somewhere around 15 thousand rpm.

Well that doesn't sound encouraging at all my friend..... What? these things are not designed to charge up batteries and require a battery charger ? That don't sound right to me.
 
really depends on the batteries on board...a group 27 battery should be rated for at least 80 amp hours....a rule 4000 gph pump draws about 20 amps...that's a few hours w/ no alternator....and two batteries will give you even more time...
 
really depends on the batteries on board...a group 27 battery should be rated for at least 80 amp hours....a rule 4000 gph pump draws about 20 amps...that's a few hours w/ no alternator....and two batteries will give you even more time...
Assuming, of course, that the pumps can stay ahead of the leak!
Really tho, a sinking on modern fiberglass boats is usually caused by an act of negligence...poor maintenance on thru hulls, forgetting to put the drain plug in, improper boat handling, etc. Your chances of sinking by "natural" causes is quite slim. Just do your maintenance and you should be good.
 
Regarding the two battery installation:
This is what we call a "two bank" system. "Bank" being the repository of energy stored in the battery. A bank can be a single or multiple batteries all grouped to form one bank. Usually these are divided into "Start" bank, and "House" bank, but you can have more banks depending on need (your 19 footer probably won't need more).
The important concept of separate banks is that you want your start battery bank to be fully charged and ready to start the engine at all times and never use it to run anything but the starter, while the house battery bank runs everything else...lights, pumps, electronics, etc.
Another important factor is isolation. You don't want to be in a situation where the start bank is bleeding voltage into the house bank. Big no on that.
In the old days, a thing called a Battery Selector Switch was used. It's a big ol rotary switch that lets you select 1, 2, ALL or none. Totally steampunk. Its main drawbacks are; possible drainage of start bank when left in the ALL position. Possible destruction of the alternator if moved when engine is running (altho there is a type that's known as make-before-break that is supposed to minimize that risk), fire hazard, and shock risk if installed incorrectly. Nice, huh? At least they are shielded so they won't throw a spark and blow you and your boat to atoms if there's fuel vapor in the area.
On the other hand it's a pretty simple setup that works if you understand it.
The modern way is with something known as a voltage sensing relay (VSR). These are solid state electronic devices that do several jobs. First they maintain the full charge on the start bank. They isolate the start battery from the house battery. They maintain the house battery when the start battery has been filled. They allow for emergency parallel of the house and start bank in case the batteries get too low. They eliminate human intervention.
There are many brands out there and they all offer this basic set of services along with other features such as optional manual switching (with a remote switch on the dash) interface with the electronics, blah blah blah.
As you can imagine these things can be accessorized with other things like battery temperature sensors, amp and volt meters, and whatever your nerdy little heart desires to keep tabs on your electrons. A couple days of cruising the waters of the Google Sea will yield a fine catch of watery information about these systems. West Marine and Jamestown Distributors, YouTube all have pretty good tech articles on these things.
My personal choice is made by Yandina. I have the Combiner 200 cz I have a 150amp alternator. Blue Sea Systems makes a nice one too. This should get you thinking about the charging system on your vessel. Always use top quality cable and terminals and finish with adhesive-lined shrink tube.
 
Last edited:
.......
If you have a two battery system, and the engine running, wouldn’t both batteries be getting juice from the alternator?
If all is working correctly....... Yes!

i have a two battery system, but haven’t ran it enough to know how well the charging system works.
With the engine running, use your VOM and take a reading directly at each battery bank.

i assumed (and I hate that word) if you were running the boat and had the selector on “all” , it would charge both batteries....???
That is correct!
However, we want to avoid selecting ALL/BOTH except for in an emergency scenario.

Oh gawd let's not get into that discussion with Post Count Rick lurking.
It's sad to see a member being so threatened by another member's contributions and post counts.

Really tho, with a 65 amp alternator it won't be able to keep up with the draw on the batteries. Even at wide open, the alternator isn't spinning at its "rated" output which is somewhere around 15 thousand rpm.
If you are referring to the load created by an operating bilge pump..... that is incorrect!

Well that doesn't sound encouraging at all my friend..... What? these things are not designed to charge up batteries and require a battery charger ? That don't sound right to me.
Don't worry or fret over his comment.
Your engine's alternator will provide more than enough juice to charge your batteries, even while operating a bilge pump.

Imagine driving your car or truck at dusk, and you turn on your headlights, only to find that the alternator will not keep up with the demand!

Regarding the two battery installation:
This is what we call a "two bank" system. "Bank" being the repository of energy stored in the battery.
Incorrect!
A battery bank is what is described in your next sentence.


A bank can be a single or multiple batteries all grouped to form one bank.

Usually these are divided into "Start" bank, and "House" bank, but you can have more banks depending on need (your 19 footer probably won't need more).
The important concept of separate banks is that you want your start battery bank to be fully charged and ready to start the engine at all times and never use it to run anything but the starter,
Yes, we refer to this as being held in "reserve".

while the house battery bank runs everything else...lights, pumps, electronics, etc.
When the house bank has been selected..... that is correct!

Another important factor is isolation. You don't want to be in a situation where the start bank is bleeding voltage into the house bank. Big no on that.
In the old days, a thing called a Battery Selector Switch was used. It's a big ol rotary switch that lets you select 1, 2, ALL or none. Totally steampunk. Its main drawbacks are; possible drainage of start bank when left in the ALL position.
No one should be selecting the ALL/BOTH mode.
That is to be used in an emergency scenario ONLY.



Possible destruction of the alternator if moved when engine is running (altho there is a type that's known as make-before-break that is supposed to minimize that risk),
You would be hard-pressed to find an MBSS today that was not "Make-before-Break".

What you DO NOT want to do, is to pass through the OFF position while the engine is running.


fire hazard, and shock risk if installed incorrectly. Nice, huh? At least they are shielded so they won't throw a spark and blow you and your boat to atoms if there's fuel vapor in the area.
Yes, these are Ignition Source Protected.
Even while they are, they should NEVER be mounted within an engine bay!
They should be in a location that offers easy and quick access.


On the other hand it's a pretty simple setup that works if you understand it.
The modern way is with something known as a voltage sensing relay (VSR). These are solid state electronic devices that do several jobs. First they maintain the full charge on the start bank. They isolate the start battery from the house battery. They maintain the house battery when the start battery has been filled.
They allow for emergency parallel of the house and start bank in case the batteries get too low.
The only style that will provide that feature, will be the Bluesea 7622ML ACR or one similar.
A standard VSR or ACR will not.

They eliminate human intervention.
There are many brands out there and they all offer this basic set of services along with other features such as optional manual switching (with a remote switch on the dash) interface with the electronics, blah blah blah.
Such as the Bluesea 500 amp 7622 ML with the remote switch.

images

 
Thanks for the detailed write up on multiple battery set ups....

I guess I’m totally steam punk....I can live with that. i have a couple large RV deep cycle batteries. No idea on amp hours or anything else. I guess I’ll see how they hold up over the long run, and keep a charger on hand where I have electricity. I do shut things off when I’m done for the day, or when not in use.

I tried out a small solar panel to trickle charge my marine battery on my small fishing boat , and wasn’t impressed with it. I had blown a fuse on my Honda outboard, and it wasn’t charging at all. It is a manual start and a sweetheart ....one pull wonder, first time , every time. But I had running lights and sonar I used the battery for. So I needed a small battery to run that. The solar charger was worthless IMO. Once I figured out the fuse issue that little 8 hp motor kept my battery up just trolling most the time.

now considering how much time I spend fishing , and trolling in particular. I may hook up that charging system on the outboard to my auxiliary battery. I’ve got my sonar power lead hooked up to that battery now. This old boat doesn’t have a lot of battery operated amenities. I believe the running lights are hooked up to the main battery and require the engine ignition to be on to run them. But that’s fine. I won’t be using those unless I’m underway anyway. An anchor light might be better ran to an auxiliary battery though.... all other cabin lights and extra goodies I add will more than likely be self contained battery operated. These newer style LED lights are incredible, and pull very little juice.

im just now getting into the wiring on this old boat. Everything looks stock, and pretty clean, but I have several gages not working. Temp is my main priority, but my trim gage is dead too..... slowLy but surely I’ll check things out.
 
................
Thanks for the detailed write up on multiple battery set ups....

I guess I’m totally steam punk....I can live with that. i have a couple large RV deep cycle batteries. No idea on amp hours or anything else. I guess I’ll see how they hold up over the long run, and keep a charger on hand where I have electricity.
Do that only if the charger is of today's Smart Charge technology.
Otherwise, you may damage them if left ON for too long.

I do shut things off when I’m done for the day, or when not in use.

I tried out a small solar panel to trickle charge my marine battery on my small fishing boat , and wasn’t impressed with it.
I'm not sure that's the way to go. When charging our battery banks, we need Amp Hours.

I had blown a fuse on my Honda outboard, and it wasn’t charging at all. It is a manual start and a sweetheart ....one pull wonder, first time , every time. But I had running lights and sonar I used the battery for. So I needed a small battery to run that. The solar charger was worthless IMO. Once I figured out the fuse issue that little 8 hp motor kept my battery up just trolling most the time.
Keep in mind that wet cell batteries prefer to be kept up to snuff.
A good rule of thumb, is to not allow them to become more than 50% depleted, and they should be charged sooner than later.

It's when they are left in a SOD (state of discharge) for any duration, that they begin to fail.


now considering how much time I spend fishing , and trolling in particular. I may hook up that charging system on the outboard to my auxiliary battery. I’ve got my sonar power lead hooked up to that battery now. This old boat doesn’t have a lot of battery operated amenities. I believe the running lights are hooked up to the main battery and require the engine ignition to be on to run them. But that’s fine. I won’t be using those unless I’m underway anyway. An anchor light might be better ran to an auxiliary battery though.... all other cabin lights and extra goodies I add will more than likely be self contained battery operated. These newer style LED lights are incredible, and pull very little juice.

Do yourself a favor (if not already existing), add a MBSS to your system.
You don't need anything fancy right now.

Run your start battery to the #1 terminal.
Run your House Load battery (preferably Deep Cycle batteries) to the #2 terminal.
The common terminal cable will run to your starter motor main lug.
Either bank selection will power things up.

If so inclined, add an ACR or VSR to the system.
This will allow the engine alternator to delegate a charge rate to either battery bank as needed.

Single engine 2 batt bank w float switch and alarm 2.jpg


im just now getting into the wiring on this old boat. Everything looks stock, and pretty clean, but I have several gages not working. Temp is my main priority, but my trim gage is dead too..... slowLy but surely I’ll check things out.

Hang in there..... you'll get it sorted out.
 
If you have a two battery system, and the engine running, wouldn’t both batteries be getting juice from the alternator?
i have a two battery system, but haven’t ran it enough to know how well the charging system works.

i assumed (and I hate that word) if you were running the boat and had the selector on “all” , it would charge both batteries....???

Keeping the switch in "all" for any period of time can lead to battery damage and shortened life. When charging only one battery, the alternator controls the amount of current that flows into the battery.... If you put the switch in "all" the alternator controls how much current leaves the alternator to the pair of batteries, HOWEVER, the "all" switch position allows current to flow from the "healthier" battery to the "less healthy" battery without any control, i.e., no limit. This high current can and will damage the batteries. My policy, wherein batt #1 is the main or start battery and #2 is a dual purpose battery is to leave the dock running on battery #1 and return on battery #2 ( bilge pump connected to #2 and boat is an open boat with non draining decks). Lately, I have had to leave the boat unattended at the dock for long periods (weeks) with weather that has been "wet".. I recently installed a single channel marine dockside battery charger wired permanently to #2 only. #1, like any car battery can go for weeks or longer without loosing a charge. In my boat, #2 gets a workout. Should #1 for what ever reason not start the engine, #2 will be fully charged.
 
Thanks for the details Rick. you are definitely into this stuff. Moo choe grassy ass seinor.
 
Last edited:
re:" i have a couple large RV deep cycle batteries"

.... some engines don't like ( and the manufacturer's installation instructions warn against them) "deep cycle" batteries for start duty.

Modern engines that are computer controlled are very picky about their batteries... for example, the original MERC VERADO outboard specifies BIG AGM batteries as start batteries.
 
re:" i have a couple large RV deep cycle batteries"

.... some engines don't like ( and the manufacturer's installation instructions warn against them) "deep cycle" batteries for start duty.

Modern engines that are computer controlled are very picky about their batteries... for example, the original MERC VERADO outboard specifies BIG AGM batteries as start batteries.

Well i better check my start battery a little closer then. She seems to be working ok for the moment. But then again she fires up instantly right now. We'll see how well it does on those cold mornings in late February when i venture forth looking for the elusive spring chinook...... I,m going to have to figure out a good place for my propane heater to set without lighting the cushions on fire before then. LOL
 
Back
Top