Logo

Cooked my '84 Evinrude?

pwskicat

Regular Contributor
1984 Evinrude 30 Long Shaft
MOD: E30ECRR
SER: FO368410
Pushing a 1984 Harris Flotebote 240 Sunliner

First nice night on the lake in all June. I get 100 yds. from my dock running @ 1/2 throttle and I hear SCREEEE and the motor quits. When I try to restart, it won't turn over. I get out the pull cord, and it won't budge. Got a tow-in from a neighbor, and now I'm writing this.

Are there definitive tests I can do to make sure it's seized before I start looking for a used replacement? Not looking for an autopsy, so I'd appreciate any tips just to determine the current state of the motor, rather than why it happened.

Many thanks for your help, PW
 
Best check oil in the lower unit.-----Then remove lower unit to see if motor will turn.-----Gas and oil mixed at 50:1 ?----Water pump impeller last replaced when, last year or 10 years ago ??
 
Best check oil in the lower unit.-----Then remove lower unit to see if motor will turn.-----Gas and oil mixed at 50:1 ?----Water pump impeller last replaced when, last year or 10 years ago ??

Thanks for your reply. Wouldn't the engine turn if it was in neutral? Gas/oil always 50:1. Usually put in a new impeller every 3 seasons.
 
Wrong !----The gear shifting is done in the lower unit.-----If bearing on pinion gear or forward gear is done in then the ,motor will NOT TURN !!----Nuetral / forward / reverse does not matter.---It will not turn.---Perhaps some of the bits under the flywheel came loose.----Check wiring that comes out.----Should be easy to determine what happened.
 
Last edited:
Wrong !----The gear shifting is done in the lower unit.-----If bearing on pinion gear or forward gear is done in then the ,motor will NOT TURN !!----Nuetral / forward / reverse does not matter.---It will not turn.---Perhaps some of the bits under the flywheel came loose.----Check wiring that comes out.----Should be easy to determine what happened.

Got it! I will pull the lower unit to check.

Would you happen to know if an 86 Evinrude 30 Pull Start (looks identical to mine but with a pull-cord engine cover) can convert to electric start? Just drop in a starter and go?

Thank u, PW
 
Pulling the boat tonite, and if the weather cooperates, dropping lower unit tomorrow to determine which system, powerhead or lower unit, is kaput.

Preparing for the worst, I've been scouring craigslist looking for a replacement motor. A 1996 Evinrude 28 SPL ($1k), and a 1990 Evinrude 30 ($1500) are most likely candidates (lotsa boats/parts here in Michigan). I'm used to 30 hp because that's what's been on the boat since I bought it. Anybody think I'll miss two ponies if I buy the cheaper motor?

Also, what parts off the old motor (besides prop) should I keep as spares? Finally, any parts worth taking to a scrap yard?

Thanks again for all the great help, PW
 
My bet its the bearing right under the water pump. If you replace the motor, I would stick to the 30, why???? They are heavier duty! The other motor you mention can be somewhat easily changed to electric start, but you want to put your charging system on too.
 
Last edited:
My bet its the bearing right under the water pump. If you replace the motor, I would stick to the 30, why???? They are heavier duty! The other motor you mention can be somewhat easily changed to electric start, but you want to put your charging system on too.

Hi Timguy. Not sure there's any difference in strength/durability between SPL and Standard-duty engines. According to the following post, SPL models lose a couple of HP and content like Power TNT and VRO so they could be sold at a budget price (just my kind of motor). http://continuouswave.com/ubb/Forum3/HTML/005043.html. The engine I found is electric start.

Sure hope you're right about the gearbox failing instead of the powerhead! I found a replacement lower unit that is a part number match for my motor. Any thing I should do/look for to make sure it's in good shape? CL photo looks super clean.

Many thanks for your help, PW
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2019-06-21 at 12.33.40 PM.jpg
    Screen Shot 2019-06-21 at 12.33.40 PM.jpg
    23 KB · Views: 86
Yes it looks clean, no salt, right? If it shifts good and has no sign of rust/contamination in the grease, then you should be fine. Check prop shaft for straight by turning it with a reference point to the tip of the shaft. When you get yours removed you will know if the trouble is in that bearing. One way to test ahead of removal is that if the motor will turn back and forth just a little wee bit, then the pistons are moving and the motion is being allowed with a little bit of play which is normal in the driveshaft splines.
You will note a smaller lower unit on the 28's with a "split case".....the "old fashioned type"........don't get me wrong, but the prop shaft is smaller diameter and things are overall a bit lighter. They are really adequate for most use. Hit a rock and you will maybe wish you had the 30. I repair them, I am an aluminum welder. I like the smaller lower units too, they seem to glide through the water a bit easier,..... but don't make any mistakes. My personal motors include both designs.
 
Last edited:
Finally got my pontoon hauled, dropped the lower unit, and the engine spun freely. Now I'm looking for a lower unit complete with short shaft for my 1984 Evinrude 30 Model E30ECRR. Turns out I have a short shaft engine, but I had it in my head that all pontoons have long shaft motors, so mine must too. The shaft on my motor measures 16-1/2" from the top of the water pump housing. Unfortunately, that rules out the super clean part I posted a pic of above.

The adventure continues...
 
Try Tim's Outboard Hackensack MN 218 682 2331 Mike or Dan, tell em Tim sent ya! Nice, clean freshwater motor parts. Lakes out that way are sandy, not as many rocks. Clean lower units.
 
Last edited:
Your driveshaft is probably shot. Needle bearing fused to it, brother. Many
pontoons have a motor mount that is lower to the water in order that they can use the lighter short shaft outboard motors.
 
Last edited:
I would hope that you are head over heels in love with that engine to spend any time repairing it. The fact that it locked up on you is a sign. Go find another.
 
It's a great motor, running like a champ for the 10 years I've owned it. The lower unit locked up because I failed to maintain it properly. i won't make that mistake again. Now that the 1996 refurbed lower unit ($420) is installed, I look forward to similar service well into the future. Outboards will run forever if properly maintained. Mine's proof.
 
Yesterday, the local mechanic I found on craigslist delivered a refurbed 1996 lower unit ($420). I installed it, put on the water muffs and Old Faithful started right up! The tell-tail was peeing, shifted smoothly both fwd and rev. The only thing I thought odd was what seemed like a lot of water spraying from the weep holes in the lower unit case. The tell-tail stream seemed a little weak, and I always have a tough time getting the water tube in place. Could the tube be outta whack? Thanks again for all the help, everybody.
 
The mechanic who sold me a refurb 1996 lower unit pulled the short shaft out of mine. He said it cleaned up just fine, so I lucked out on that. I located a NOS short shaft on ebay that I was ready to buy for $100 if needed. Investing $420 plus some time saved me a lot over spending anywhere from $1000 to $2200 for one of the engines I found on CL. :cool:
 
Excellent. Did he say where the "freeze-up" happened? Must not have been in that shaft bearing? I say that because the needles up there are the first to "run dry" and normally damage the shaft beyond use. Even the smaller and earlier motors, the shaft would get damaged just as much as the bronze bushing that it ran through. Just doing a 1969 6 Johnson right now with bad shaft and bushings. It is crazy that a hardened steel shaft can wear just as much as a soft bronze bushing/sleeve.
 
I was so glad to hear that my shaft wasn't damaged, and so anxious to get home and install the lower unit that I didn't ask what broke. Sorry.
 
If you ever have the chance to talk with him again be sure to ask him. That would be great just for our own information. Did you get the old unit back? I will buy it from you, need housings and parts for these. One of a type of very popular outboard lower units.
 
If you ever have the chance to talk with him again be sure to ask him. That would be great just for our own information. Did you get the old unit back? I will buy it from you, need housings and parts for these. One of a type of very popular outboard lower units.

He kept the old case. I'm back on the water and am 100% satisfied. I ordered a new keep for the gearshift shaft because the current one looks pretty haggard. I'll put the new one in the next time I rebuild the water pump. That little piece of plastic cost 12.50 with free shipping and that was the best bargain I could find. There are folks selling them for over $20 when u add in shipping!

Thanks again everybody for your help.
 
Back
Top