Dennis, hang in there. I'm rather sorry that you are needing to wade through a little disagreement here. Also hope that which ever advice you take to be worthy, that it helps you out.
And again, I think that you are wise to be questioning yourself and investigating this.
After I get it all installed I am going to start with my timing at 6*BTDC with the engine idling as slow as I can get it to keep any advance out of it. I'll see how happy it is from there.
Dennis, if this means checking to see where the progressive advance is..... excellent!
That's all I've been suggesting.... whether on-engine, or in a shop on a distributor machine.
Dennis, I will question Mark's timing specs, and perhaps Mark will come back and qualify.
Mark said:
The timing spec for full advance is 25 deg @ 2,200 rpm to 28 deg @ 1,800 rpm then no advance after that up to max rpm.
If the 25 deg @ 2,200 rpm includes all advance (BASE and Mechanical) it seems early to me.... but you could certainly verify this.
However, there is something definitely wrong with the
28 deg @ 1,800 rpm
IMO, it would very important to verify this.
*********************************************
Kghost, you say that you're not arguing and that you want to clear things up. I agree... let's clear things up.
It's all the more important that we don't add to any confusion or misrepresentation by bickering back and forth, nor do we need to tout our experience and puff up our feathers!
We need to help these people, but also need to understand that many do not have the same skill levels that we may have.
Let's arm these people with what will best serve them as to prevent issues, even if this means a bit of "Over-Explaining" re; certain aspects...., then hope that they are more able to make a educated decision.
That's why they're here in the first place.
Take the mechanical progressive ignition advance, for example... since it has become the additional topic of discussion.
Most all OEM service or work shop manuals will offer ignition timing specs that include base advance and TA.
Mark was able to find his OEM specs... although there's a bit of qualification needed re; the
28 deg @ 1,800 rpm.
Not only does the OEM suggest a TA, but the RPM at which TA is to occur.
The OEM has given us these specs for very good reason.
Kghost, I highly doubt that you tune up a Marine Engine by setting base advance and without additionally looking at the progressive advance to verify that it is correct and within specs.
For those of us who do not look further, I believe that we are doing a disservice to ourselves AND to our customers.
You also mentioned "Pre-Ignition" in one of your previous posts...... pre-ignition is NOT the main concern.
Perhaps you are confusing Pre-Ignition with Detonation. These are two entirely different phenomenon.
Detonation can be very difficult to hear and detect while cruising down the water with an engine hatch closed.
.