Logo

compression results

redsnapper386

Regular Contributor
guys i recently did a compression test after a hydrolock.here are results of dry test.#1-150 #3-120 #5-159 #7-165.#2-205 #4-185 #6-198 #8-198.this is a 350,.030 flat tops,carb,300 h.p.approx.the motor spins over good with no unusual noise as the motor was fogged right away.it seems to me that the #1 thru #7 is strange.are these readings acceptable.i will be pulling the heads off and having them checked.the manifolds and risers are in the trash-cast iron.need opinions.thanks in advance.
 
It looks like the left bank took a bath. How long did she swim? Do a wet comp. test to see how much change there is espec. on 1, 3, 5 & 7 cylinders. If there is little change the rings could be ok. When you replace the exhaust components get quality parts...Barr, Osco, Merc (but not the cheapies). Don't even consider GLM--you'll get what you pay for. Don't forget the exhaust shutters.
 
Ayuh,... I'm with DMS, you've still got water or something in the even cylinders, hence the high numbers...
 
Ditto Chris re; warming the engine up and doing a fresh Comp Test when she cools back down!

Bill makes a good point regarding water being in the Stbd bank (#2 thru #8) and this causing the high readings... .... but why so evenly???
Did you by chance squirt a large quantity of oil in these cylinders prior to the comp test????


guys i recently did a compression test ..............
here are results of dry test.
1.... #1-150 #3-120 #5-159 #7-165.
2.... #2-205 #4-185 #6-198 #8-198.
3.... this is a 350 ,.030 flat tops,
4.... it seems to me that the #1 thru #7 is strange.
5..... are these readings acceptable?
6... i will be pulling the heads off and having them checked

OK, I'm suggesting the following due to the difference that I'm reading between the Port and Stdb sides.


1.... This would be the Port side...... #'s 5 and 7 are acceptible..... #1 is low, #3 @ 120 is very low. Something is wrong here.

2.... This would be the Stbd side...... these readings are high, but are likely acceptible with regard to the % of differential, but again something is wrong with these higher readings.

3.... For the Marine SBC 5.7L, Flat Top pistons are suitable with 76cc chamber cylinder heads..... not 64cc chambers!

4.... Yes, it is strange to me also!
With #3 above in mind, I'm going to suggest that the Stbd cylinder head may be a 64cc chamber casting, and that the Port cylinder head is a 76cc chamber casting....... or somewhere in the neighborhood of those.

5.... No, not with the % of differential, IMO.

6..... I'd pull the valve covers and look at the casting numbers. I'd then go to http://www.nastyz28.com/sbchevy/sbch.php or this web site http://www.auto-ware.com/techref/castnum.htm and see if your casting number is listed.
The chamber volume should be listed in one of these web sites. There are many cylinder head combustion chamber volumes for the SBC.
I don't know how anyone could mis-match these....., but never say never.


The Flat Top piston is a great choice for a Marine SBC. With the correct deck height and head gasket, you can give this a good quench area.... very important for Marine use, IMO.
However, this piston should be accompanied with the 76cc chamber head to keep the C/R correct... ( unless this is for a small Hot Rod boat )


.
 
Last edited:
guys,sorry for posting back late.i agree about the heads,and it is very possible that the machine shop mixed up my heads.i appreciate all input.i am in the process of tearing things apart. i will post back later.this is a mystery to me,and it is probably something simple.the tear down will tell.thanks.
 
guys,sorry for posting back late.i agree about the heads,and it is very possible that the machine shop mixed up my heads.i appreciate all input.i am in the process of tearing things apart. i will post back later.this is a mystery to me,and it is probably something simple.the tear down will tell.thanks.

If you are tearing down the engine already, you jumped the gun. Why did you bother to post here for advice?
 
chris i am removing the heads because i feel they are the wrong heads,also they need to be reconditioned.the numbers in side both heads are-14102193.these came off the stock 350-260 h p.are these the right heads for .030 flat tops.i think i have 64cc,and should be 76cc.mistake by me or machine shop.thanks.
 
chris let me ask a question? how would you determine if a motor had wiped rings.you think maybe a tear down,or do you have x-ray vision.how would you determine a warped valve,bad seals,cracked valve guide from cold water meeting 800 degree temps more or less.after all hydrolock causes big problems.
 
Read post three, four and five.

I don't need x-ray vision to figure this problem out.

Your original post says "i will be pulling the heads off and having them checked."

If the engine was fogged after it was filled with water and not restarted and run up to temp to clear itself, you are getting incorrect compression readings due to the fog oil. If your heads were damaged in any way IE...warped valve,bad seals,cracked valve guide, You would have low compression or no compression with or with out fog oil in the cylinders. Unless you plan on pulling the engine for a complete rebuild, you disassembled it before you completely diagnosed it.

I am only here to help point you in the right direction!

Engines hydro-lock all the time with out doing any damage.
 
Last edited:
chris,good points.i was hoping someone could tell me what heads i have.numbers are 14102193. what is the cc.if they are not 76cc,what size should i have with .030 flat tops. can not find any info on links.if the heads are wrong then i want to get it right.also, i think my machine shop messed up.
 
The 14102193's are listed at 65.3cc combustion chambers. I think they are swirl port heads. That cumbustion chamber size with a flat top piston will give you approx compression of 9.5:1
 
Do not take the advice on head cc's and piston type completely to heart. Not that is bad advice it is not, it is good advice BUT.....

There is nothing wrong with your heads and pistons as long as the correct camshaft was chosen by your engine builder.

If it does not ping and the power out put was good (as good as one can judge while driving the boat without actually dyno ing the motor) then component selection is not an issue.

With a smaller cc head 64 (which you have) vs 76 (reccommended in previous post) You have a smaller combustion chamber and slightly higher compression ratio. You will be more suseptable to pinging especially with a non adjustable ignintion. (thunderbolt IV and V) have a factory timing advance curve.

You may be forced to run 89 + octane to accomidate this set up but you will have to determine this by ear.

Concentrate on what Chris is advising for now and not the component selection of a motor that was allready running.........

I have recovered several engines that have had hydrolock myself. I also have seen many with pistons thru the cyclinder walls. It all depends on the conditions when this occurred and if the operator tried to restart and or run when in this condition.

Post your results
 
thanks ghost.i did notice a slight hesitation between 1000 thru 1800 rpm.after that it runs great.this is a stock gm cam with 400 lift.all the rebuild parts are new.when the motor hydrolocked we were offshore in a 2 ft chop.the motor was off for approx 15 min.tried to start,no start.also the bow of the boat had xtra gear.dive gear ect.this is the only thing that was different from other trips.i want to cover all bases here in order to nail the problem.we now go back to the glm x-aust which is in the trash.who knows.i do know that i had no problem with the stock merc x-aust,just old and clogged.i have a spare set of heads if needed.can you tell me what cc these are-no.14096217.thanks.
 
The 14102193 is a light casting and is not recommended for a Marine application.
I think that Chris is correct. The chamber volume is 64cc, and given the year range of these, that would be in line with small chambers, IMO.

Notice the full scallops at the lower section.
The scallops typical show which castings are the light weight castings, such as these below.

H4845-4.jpg

H4845-4.jpg




cylinder_head_for_chevy_350.jpg


The heavy castings will be similar to this:
images


Read post #5 again regarding the Flat Top pistons and cylinder head chamber volume.

With F/T's, a 4.000" bore, a 3.480" stroke and 64cc chambers and using a decent quench dimension at the gasket....., the static C/R will be in the range of 10.9969:1
If I toss in 2cc for valve reliefs, I come up with 10.73416:1.

This is on the high side for Marine loads without taking extra and careful measures elsewhere.


Here is Sick's Engine Compression Ratio calculator... run the static C/R specs for yourself.
http://cleanandsober.741.com/CompressionCalculator.html


Kghost mentions pinging.
Understand that pinging from "Pre-Ignition" is not the same as "Detonation". These are two entirely different phenomena.
We can typically hear pre-ignition.... but we cannot always hear detonation and we should pay more attention to detonation potential.
Increased C/R does not necessarily cause "pinging"..... pinging is typically a result of early ignition per RPM and/or carbon retaining heat within the cylinder.
Increased C/R can cause detonation..... and it can be ignition induced.
We should never confuse the two with one another..... in particular with the Marine Engine.

As for the 14096217 casting #.......one search leads us to this:
14096217 Iron heads, They are 1987+ (and later) and
feature 72 degree center bolts. Valves are 1.94 and 1.5 with 64cc combustion
chambers.


Another search leads us to this:
14096217…55-86…350……….Crate motor, 285hp/300hp, 64cc chambers, 72' or 90' center intake

While each shows some different year applications, it looks like the chamber volume is 64cc.
If this is correct, and if used with the F/T pistons,
you'll end up with the same C/R issue.



.
 
Last edited:
thanks ricardo and to all. this is big help.i have both set of heads and was unaware of the differance.guys i just wonder if the new glm axaust came with a defect or leak and therefore allowing some water to leak back into the x-aust ports and then causing that hesitation at low rpm.or even bad riser gaskets.i did also notice motor was hard to start when cold.stainless marine has 3 inch taller than stock riser and longer length going to elbow.has anyone seen this situation before.thanks.
 
The only thing here that is worth discussing is the possiblility of too high compression. This is NOT his issue. He had hydrolock from a boat in water with the engine OFF!

Also a hesitation at 1000 - 1800 rpms has no relevance here either. that could be timing, air/feul ratio/carb or several other runability issues but not relevent here.

The quench issue is valid but we dont know what head gasket was used. I doubt it was a exotic thickness.
Most likely a standard thickness of .046"-.054".
Not 100 % sure of a stock thickness.

As anyone who has played with quench one would know a target of .030" to .035" is prefered. We dont know what the piston hieght is or the gasket thickness.
Did his engine biulder purchase a non standard or stock thickness? He will have to find out.

Now back to the real issue at hand HYDROLOCK!!!!!

This is caused by only a few potential issues.

1. Thru hull exhaust and the elbows hieght to close to water level outside of boat. is this boat thru hull or thru prop exhaust????
2. rough seas causing excessive back flush with motor not running.
3. bad manifold and or leaking gaskets/manifolds/elbows.
4. blown head gasket.
5. cracked heads.
6. High lift/high duration cam causing a reversion condition. Obviously this is not the case!
There may be more, please add to this list!

So you need to eliminate each of these to figure out what happened.

1. Manifold and elbows, each need the water passages to be sealed off and air pressure or smoke applied to see if they leak.
2. look at boat/motor install instructions to see if the water level outside vs elbow hieght is correct to avoid back flush.
3. Cam is good .400 lift is a wimpy cam so no issues there!!

the rest you will need to check, cracks, head gasket failure, manifold gaskets torn leaking.
 
http://www.marineengine.com/boat-forum/showthread.php?396698-gen-iv-saltwater-in-cylinders

I pulled two engines from two separate vessels this week, A FWC 7.4 Mercruiser inboard in a 40 Trojan which the owner installed a new set of GLM manifolds and riser. He locked the engine up a few times because the manifold and riser mating surfaces were defective. Eventually the gasket let loose and poured sea water into the number 8 hole bent the connecting rod, broke the piston and windowed the block.

Engine #2, 5.7 Mercruiser Alpha 1 GLM manifolds (Owner installed trying to say $$$) on a raw water engine, the risers were porous and sweating water through the iron. This would have been a repairable problem except the boat sat for a couple of weeks and the sea water locked up the wet cylinder.

So in short, if you still have the manifolds and risers, pressure test them to remove the possibility of them being the cause from the equation.
 
Kghost, no offense was intended behind my comments re; pre-ignition and detonation. I don't ever want to step on anyone's toes here!
Your points are all well taken!
The OP's thread title is "compression results" .... and IMO the OP has an excessive C/R on the Stbd side for Marine use.
I wanted to qualify that "Pre-ignition" and "Detonation" were not the same as to not confuse him.

As I see this, the OP's issues are two fold:
1.... he has odd readings between the two cylinder banks, and in particular the high readings on the Stbd side.
2.... he has an issue with this hydro-locking.

#1 is what got me thinking about and talking about the possibility of different castings and chamber volumes.
Keep in mind that when I plugged in rather conservative numbers, I come up with 10.73416:1 C/R.
So part of my focus has been re; this issues, whereas you are focusing more so on the hydro-locking.
Both are valid concerns and need to be addressed, IMO.


Chris, I too have read where people have had issues with the GLM manifolds.


.
 
Last edited:
ghost and all,thanks. the exaust is through prop.the head gaskets are stock size from sierra.this all i can say at this point.will double check all these items on reassemble.glms are in trash.definitley will confirm and correct elbow water ht.to water issue.it is possible that my stern is to heavy.i do have new y-pipe water shutters installed.just to add,all of the rust puddles,and rust rings were mostly found in the bottom section of exaust manifolds. less was found in riser sections.the more these dry out the more i see. thanks.
 
Back
Top