"Ted, ran some numbers for you
"Ted, ran some numbers for you and while the 19 pitch is a little much, you are not severely over-propped.
My calculator kicked out a 15 pitch if you tend to run "heavy" (near max capacity) and a 17 pitch otherwise.
If you have a tach onboard, you should be looking for about 5200-5300 rpms running wide open. If you are getting somewhat less than that, for every 1" less pitch you run compared to your current 19", you would see an increase of about 200 rpms.
So I would tend to suspect that the boat not getting on plane is not entirely due to the prop. Since you have added extra weight to the stern (kicker) you may simply have to adjust your trim from what you were used to, to get the bow to sit back down properly and get the lift at the stern.
Alternately, a hydrofoil or trim tabs may do the trick if adequate compensation can not be achieved with trim alone..."