Before you pull hoses, prime, etc, tell us which style belt driven Sherwood Pumps you have!
And tell us which engine this pump is fitted to... (the Standard LH Rotation, or the Reverse RH Rotation engine)?
There are several styles of this belt driven pump, some of which are very easy to install 180* out of correct indexing.... and in particular when we have LH and RH engines.
These belt driven pumps, for example:
If any of the above pumps are out of phase by 180* (as per engine rotation), they will not pump water.
This pump in this orientation would be for a Standard LH engine (CW if viewed from the front of this pump).
Note how the impeller blades would open as they leave the pump cam, (creating suction) .... then folding at the cam again (creating pressure).
(all in a clockwise direction for a LH engine when viewing from the front of the pump)
This same pump in this orientation would be for a Reverse RH Rotation engine (CCW if viewed from the front of this pump).
Again, note how the blades would open leaving the pump cam.... folding again upon contacting the cam...
(all in a counter clockwise direction for a RH engine when viewing from the front of the pump)
The important thing to note, is that:
Suction is created as the impeller blades "leave" the cam and open back up.... causing the area between blades to become larger.
Pressure is created as the impeller blades "fold upon" the cam... causing the area between blades to become smaller.
I don't know which pump you have...., but this may be as simple as flipping the pump over 180*.
.