"If Your boat did some 65 knot
"If Your boat did some 65 knots at wot with the Renegade, You may have been close, but still too far off max rated rpm hp, if following the rating and rule. I do not have all the datas on the old 235, but going 10% up from max rated rpm, encreases Your consumption with close to 10% and You loose almost 10% of the engine power!
Personally I never recomended and used the Renegades as I found them extreemely poor in general consumption. Worked on light boats at high speed, but for general use 'expencive'to run.
Normally I used the 'old' type Viper or Rakers for those after the top end speed up to around 50+ knots, and in a couple of cases Shooters.
My daughters used to sell ice cream on beaches and islands using 5 and 5,5m ribs. I had the boats equipped with every thing from 35 to 70 hp 2-strokes, 4-strokes and E-tech. Whatever 2-stroke I used their average daily consumption was 30Liters+ no matter engine size. For the 4 strokes and E-Tecs the consumption was 20+ liters. So for ombined use there is no doubt that the E-techs/4-strokes are fuel savers. But note that the E-tech 50 almost had the same top end speed as the 70 4-stroke and I could drive in circles around the 70 4-stroke with the 70 2-stroke! But this has all to do with boat type, ballance etc. In another case with a quite heavy 20ft daycruiser I replaced a 90 2-stroke with a 70 4-stroke, His top en dropped from 28 to 25 knots (gps), but his average consumption on a day trip dropped 50%! It is a lot of 'thumb rules', but some thumbs are rather small, some are big and thick! "Factory tests' may be used as a rough indicator, but they are only valied for that specific boat, at that day, under the circumstances during the test, at the specific rpm for the specific engine with the specific prop ...........!"