Rudy, hopefully you have a good spare propeller that should be identical to the prop that you normally run.
This must be an AQ series propeller without any "thru-prop" exhaust porting.
Also, make sure that you are using the correct "spinner" and not a prop nut!
Install the spare prop and go give it another try.
Also, we will normally see an OEM specified WOT RPM "range" that should become our target. I do not believe that the high side will be 5,500 RPM. I would think that this will be more in the range of 4,400 to 4,800 RPM.
Double check your OEM service manual!
In order to test for WOT RPM, the hull must be clean, engine in full tune, and the final gear reduction must be correct for the Engine.
Your Engine will require the 1.61:1 over-all reduction.
To find the gear ratio (the over-all reduction), remove your propeller, remove the ring anode and take a wire brush to the AFT-most area of the prop shaft bearing carrier. The ratio will be stamped into the carrier and should read 1.61 (the :1 will be omitted).
(no other ratio will work for this engine)
While on the topic of a rebuild that renders more power........ make dang sure that your ignition system is delivering the correct "Progressive" spark advance and the correct "Total Advance" at the correct RPM.
Short of no oil pressure and/or over-heating........ Ignition Induced Detonation is the gasoline Marine Engine's worst enemy!
.