Logo

Alternator wired direct to the battery

bulletine

Regular Contributor
The other day I read a post and one person stated there is a improvement when alternator is wired direct to the battery and not the starter.

I have low voltage on my starboard engine volt gauge, the analog meter on the main DC panel shows a bit over 13 volts, the same voltage as the port engine. I will troubleshoot tomorrow or the next day to find out if the alternator should be replaced. The alternators appear to be a Motorola 50 AMP #39049, I have a ARCO #60104 replacement that came with the boat that I will use as a replacement if needed.

I thought as part of the troublshooting process, I would like to change the wire from the starter to the battery. If I should do this, is it good to use a butt connector to extend the wiring to reach the battery, or should I run a new wire. I was thinking maybe a 10 AWG, any thoughts?

Thanks.
 
Personally I wouldn't bother with repositioning the charge wire. You most likely have a wiring issue, corrosion, poor connection, bad gauge etc. Did you take a reading at the gauge with a meter? Make sure all connections are clean and tight including grounds. Also pull apart the main engine harness plug and check pins for corrosion etc.
 
Agreed. Use a hand held meter to confirm what the gage is saying.

Jeff

PS: One of my Perko battery switches has 'dirty' contacts. I can gain a full volt by working the switch ON/ OFF, ON/ OFF a few dozen times. Try that as well.
 
Agreed that the problem is probably the connections and not the path taken by the electricity. Disassemble and clean all of your connections and coat with a protective agent such as Corrosion-X when reassembling.
 
I agree with what I think Woodie is suggesting.
Examine your engine harness thoroughly, and find out if there is an issue.
IOW, do not circumvent the OEM system...... find what's wrong and make a correct repair.


I do not make any "direct" battery connections other than POS and NEG battery cables themselves.
Small wire terminals are much more prone to corrosion at the batteries than the larger cable terminals are.

In addition, I absolutely dispise the potential "Rat's Nest" that we often see in/around battery banks.
There is ZERO need for this, IMO......... POS/NEG battery cables ONLY!

We have a near perfect "schematically identical" Alternator termination point right at the starter motor soloenoid lug.
Usually the engine harness provides this circuit.

If your system is equipped with an MBSS (main battery selector switch), the Engine Alternator charge is then directed to the battery bank that is currently "Selected".
No need to take this out of the loop, IMO.

As for the Perko.... don't get me started! :mad:
Over the years I've had more trouble, and have replaced more Perko MBSS's than any other..... especially the 90* sweep style.
URL]


IMO, a 90* sweep is not adequate to incorporate correct size contacting and the Make-Before-Break feature.
I think that Cole Hersee, BlueSea, Guest... are a much better MBSS.

BTW.... our Alternator Negative connections can be equally important.
We'll normally see a short Neg lead connecting the Alternator chassis to the Engine block.

.
 
Last edited:
As long as the starter works properly, there isn't any need to move the charging lead from the battery terminal at the starter.

If you have a 'long' wiring harness, there may be benefit in relocating the 'sense' lead closer to the battery. many times, especially with older installs, the long wire length plus 'aging' results in a voltage drop between the battery and the regulator. Another known culprit is adding too many 'taps' into the instrument panel harness (usually trailer boats w/o breaker panels).

Like Rick noted, the dedicated grounds on most alternators are ignored and can be a major source of charging issues.
 
Thanks to all. I will check all the connections and clean as I go. Last month, I sprayed the alt connections with corrosion x, hoping that would help but did little. I will start with the dash gauge (I have to lift the dash panel to access the back of the gauges and since I have done this often the problem may be there) From there I will work at the alternator, then to the starter connections.

All my accessory connections are made through the switches as suggested by Ricardo months ago. As for the Perko switches, I have 4. I will have to think about changing them out later, when I do I most likely will go with Blue Seas.
 
UPDATE

The other day I removed the wires from the voltage guage in the dash, cleaned them and added dielectric grease. Today, I removed and cleaned the wires from the starter and dist today, I used dielectric grease on the terminals and sprayed the starter terminals with liquid electrical tape.

I started the engine and the voltage meter was right where is should be, in the middle. Then in a few seconds it dropped back to where is has been, about a 1/4.
Tomorrow I will do the same on the alternator. I am wondering now if it is not the Yandina combiner that is causing the voltage drop, because when I did start the engine and the voltage was reading charge, my thinking is then the combiner kicked in and resulted in the voltage drop. I will continue to the alternator tomorrow
and if the problem persists, I will call Yandina, they are always very helpful.

Thanks to all who helped.
 
Using the ole tried and proven P or E (process of elimination), it's always best to do one item at a time, IMO.
When/if the the one item corrects the problem, we find ourselves better equipped for a similar problem in the future.

If we throw parts at 3 or 4 items all at once, or dink around with 3 or 4 items all at once, we may never know which fixed the problem! :D

.
 
Again, Thanks for the help. I heard from Yandina after sending them the wiring diagram I made and they say everything is wired correctly and the combiners are working. I got sidetracked due to the heat and rebuilt my Raritan head because the cabin has A/C. Next step beginning tomorrow is to disconnect the combiner to test and then check all the alternator connections and work back to the dist.
 
Back
Top