"Dave, the Verado is a well bu
"Dave, the Verado is a well built 4 stroke based on little to no issues being raised on forums such as this. However, to be fair, they haven't been in production long enough to determine if they have any (legacy) issues. Their "initial" quality appears to be quite good.
You could argue that really the way to go would be with a Honda - all bias aside they are most probably the best built 4 stroke on the market.
I am not fond of 4 strokes, and I don't think you will find a ringing endorsement for them anywhere on this board. They cost too much, weigh too much, the power band sucks, the torque band sucks and they require 4 to 5 times as much maintenance time compared to their 2 stroke counterparts. Plus, they will not tolerate being ignored. You might get away without following the maint schedule for a year or two, then after that you have 600 pounds of scrap metal.
I would not rate the Yamaha or Suzuki 4 stoke any better than the Merc, but as noted above, none are in the same class as the Honda.
Is there any reason you are not considering a Direct Injected 2 stroke 250 Optimax? It weighs in at over 100 pounds lighter, will save you a few thousand bucks in intial cost, requires almost no maintenance and will kick the snot out of any outboard currently on the market for power and torque, and is just as fuel efficient and clean (EPA rated) as any 4 stroke out there...
Talk to any "reputable" Merc tech (not a salesman) and they will tell you there is just no comparison between the Opti and a 4 stroke.
Oh ya, it is hard on spark plugs though
Just asking..."