"Chris, it's nearly imposs
"Chris, it's nearly impossible to determine what prop to use off a chart - there is just way too many variables.
For example, the chart says use prop "x" for 17-19' boats - a 17 foot aluminum may way 900 pounds dry, a 19 foot tri-hull fibreglass may way 1700 pounds dry - there is no way the same pitch prop will push both effiently.
To properly calculate what prop is suitable for a particular rig you need to know hull type, waterline length, total displacement (including boat, motor, gear, rigging and load), horsepower and max prop diameter. That will allow you to calculate a reasonable prop to start with.
And the year of the motor is important as well. Your 1979 model was rated in BHP (Brake Horsepower at the crank). By today's standards you have a 135 horse SHP (Shaft Horsepower) motor. Most charts do not make that distinction, so you would be turning "too much prop" by their guidelines regardless of how accurate they made them.
From there, it's a matter of running the prop selected and then fine tuning using a tach on your rig as you actually run it. A decent calculator will normally select a reasonable prop. A paper chart is best used for starting the fireplace when the boat is in winter storage...
With the numbers you have posted, you should be looking to move to a 17 pitch to get into the rpm range where the motor should be running.
And to me a 17 pitch on an 18 footer sounds about correct with the load you describe..."