#2 is wrong ! the distributor rotor does not have to "point", at the physical location of the number one spark plug. it has to only point at the physical location wher the number one ignition wire is.
First of all Mr. Crankbait, and with all due respect, no one implied that this is a rule..... it is a preference only.
please explain the mechanical correlation of the distributor rotor and it pointing to the location of the number one hole.
For the experienced mechanic, it could be said that there becomes a rhyme and reason (I.E., preference) for aiming/pointing the rotor towards the physical location of #1 cylinder.
Many of us prefer to aim/point the rotor towards the #1 cylinder's physical location while at/near TDC C/S for #1 cylinder.
GM apparently agrees:
Oldsmobile apparently agrees:
Pontiac apparently did not agree:
if the number one cylinder is on the compression stroke, and you have the line on the harmonic balancer lined up on the timing tab at @ 6-8 degrees advance, you can drop the distributor in any position you want, as long as you engage the oil pump drive, and put the number one wire in the hole that the rotor is pointing at.
I have no disagreement with that at all....... as long as we begin our indexing with #1 cylinder, the distributor cap does not care about which way we index the #1 spark plug wire.
And I'll go one better by telling you that if you are experience, you do not even need to align the harmonic balancer marks @ 6-8 degrees advance.
However, for average Joe who may not be experienced and who is asking for forum help, we suggest a method that is tried and proven.
You do as you choose..... I will continue with my usual suggestion based on many years of experience.
Fair enough???? 