Get your engine model number and look in marineengine.com for the parts listing for your model number. In the gearcase section you will find all the prop sizes and their numbers that you can use. From there it is go to Michigan Wheel and Turning Point propellers websites and they have a prop selector, Michigan Wheel calls theirs "Outboard Sizing Analysis". Turning Point calls it "Prop Wizard". With those you can narrow it down to likely two sizes. From there it's matter of asking other people who have the same setup. If you have a tachometer that is the way to figure out which is the best one for you. If you do not have a tachometer, then just do all the above and make your pick and go with it. I'd recommend the Turning Point Hustler aluminum props because they have a hub that can be used on multiple props, so if your first choice is not optimal, you can buy another prop without a hub and it is much cheaper.