MarineEngine.com does not offer troubleshooting assistance or repair advice by email or by telephone.
You are invited to join our public Boat Repair Forum to seek assistance from other members.
You may also visit the Boat Motor Manuals section of our site to obtain a service manual.
How did it all work out in the end ? I guess that the 19P prop you had was overloading the engine at WOT... and the 17P is better matched.
For reference: I have a Mercruiser 4.3MPI Alpha One Gen 2 with a 15 1/2 inch 17P stainless prop on a 21 foot Fibreglass Cuddy Cabin boat. I can manage 30 knots at 4000rpm and 32 knots (37mph) at 4400rpm with just me in the boat and a full fuel and water load (just tested this and measured speeds from 3000-4400 rpm).
This matches the theoretical curve really well ... using pitch (17 +1 for cupping), 1.81 gear ratio, 10% slip. And it matches Couches formula quite well for a heavy planing boat (mine is 2000kg)