MarineEngine.com does not offer troubleshooting assistance or repair advice by email or by telephone.
You are invited to join our public Boat Repair Forum to seek assistance from other members.
You may also visit the Boat Motor Manuals section of our site to obtain a service manual.
So then a long hub propeller is basically a short hub propeller that has the forward spinner spacer built in to the aft end of the propeller beyond the splines?
A long hub propeller is just that...... a propeller with a longer inner hub than that of the Standard inner hub propeller.
The long hub propeller will typically have larger blades!
The "spinner" is the nut, or "cone nut" shown as "D" below... (D = aft section of the 2 pc...... the 1 pc is not shown).
The "spacer" or "spacer/line cutter" is shown as "A" below.
250/270/275 = short spacer/line cutter regardless of which prop.
280/285/290/SP etc, = long spacer/line cutter regardless of which prop.
Ricardo - quit teasing me and post a picture of the back end of a long hub prop!
What was the reason for short and long hubs?
If either works would it not be better to just have one style.
Y'all can tell by all my questions that I have been very confused by the long/short hub situation.
Don't feel alone! Many have trouble understanding this.
Plus Jeff, there is far too much Mis-Information out there regarding this topic.
I've even seen and read where Prop Shops refer to AQ series Short/Long shafts and don't get the spacer/line cutter info correct!
Here is what I think I have learned:
If you have a long hub shaft - the one that's threaded, and a two piece cone, you can use any Aquamatic propeller - the short hub with the cone spacer, the long hub without - along with the locking bolt.
Again, try thinking of this as though there is NO long hub shaft..... and think in terms of all shafts NETTING the same length of shaft and exposed splines when the correct spacer/line cutter is used.
We cannot use the incorrect spacer/line cutter because that would place the propeller differently on the shaft/splines.
Examples:
**250/270/275 with the incorrect long spacer/line cutter.... the prop will sit too far AFT.
**280/285/290 with the incorrect short spacer/line cutter..... the prop will sit too far FWD and will cause interference with the ring anode and bearing carrier.
If you have the short hub shaft, any Aquamatic propeller will fit, but you'll not be able to lock on the spinner w/ bendy tabs using the long hub propeller and you'll likely end up losing the propeller.
Again, think of this as though there is NO long hub shaft..... all shafts NET the same length of shaft and exposed splines when the correct spacer/line cutter is used.
There was a TSB that suggested threading short hub shafts to use the locking bolt instead of the bendy tabs - if yours is one of these you can use a long hub prop (sans cone spacer) with the locking bolt
If we were to drill and thread tap a non-internally threaded prop shaft, we would loose the nickel/chrome plating.
If you want to fit a Solas short hub prop to your short hub shaft, you'll either need to reduce the line cutter/spacer by about 1/8" or trim the same amount off the front or back of the Solas prop to allow use of the bendy tab.
Again... no short shaft, and under normal conditions, we do not trim any material from the spacer/line cutter.
I'd have to say that the prop is the problem..... not the shaft or spacer/line cutter!
The Solas short hub prop can be used with any threaded shaft without modification if you use the cone with the spacer and the locking bolt.
The short hub prop can be used with either style lower unit and with either the SS tab washer or the 1 pc spinner or both parts of the 2 pc spinner with the center locking bolt.
I believe the long hub propeller was introduced with the advent of the threaded shaft.
With the "internally threaded" shaft.... yes.
There was no longer a need for the bendy tab so the spacer part of the cone was added to the propeller, simplifying propeller attachment by using the locking bolt.
Actually, the spacer portion of the 2 pc spinner is omitted when the long hub prop is used.
IOW, only the AFT portion of the 2 pc spinner (along with the center locking bolt) is used for this prop.
If the propeller shaft is indeed a 280 shaft......
and if the spacer/line cutter is the correct OEM "LONG" spacer/line cutter.......
and if the propeller is an OEM Volvo Penta prop........
and if the SS locking tab washer (or the white plastic washer) is an OEM Volvo Penta part ......
and if the spinner is an OEM spinner (aka cone nut) .......,
then all should fit and work as per how Volvo Penta intended!
.
Thanks!
That's a lot of "if's" but I think I can answer every single one with a Yes. Could you perhaps confirm the length of the long line cutter?
Would someone mind explaining to me why we would not want to use the correct OEM parts ???????
First, the OEM parts are extremely expensive compared to aftermarket.
Second, we may have OEM parts, but because our rigs are 40 years old we don't know whether we have the correct OEM parts or not.
Third, we often don't know which parts are correct because of the interchangeability of the Aquamatic drives.
With the AQ series stern drives (up through the SP drive), there are only two lengths for these prop shafts, and only two lengths found with the spacer/line cutter.
When the correct spacer/line cutter is used for the shaft..........., all shafts NET the same length of prop hub splines.
The above information is not relevant to anyone trying to fit a propeller on an Aquamatic drive. If it fit's I wouldn't be asking, if it doesn't fit, tell me if there's any way I can make it work.
.
So here's my take...
If your cone leaves a gap when you fit your prop, you probably are using a 250 line cutter instead of the longer 280. If you don't want to invest in the OEM 280 line cutter, you can shim the shorter one between the cutter and prop.
So I reread this thread from the beginning and at one point I did measure/post both the 250 and the 280 line cutter measurements.That's correct for me anyway + it's easier since I don't have a Penta dealer nearby.
So I reread this thread from the beginning and at one point I did measure/post both the 250 and the 280 line cutter measurements.
The 250 measures .625
The 280 measures 1.375
And when I used the Solas prop with the 250 line cutter (on the 250 drive), I needed to make the 250 line cutter 1/8" shorter so the bendy tab could grab the splines.
If your propeller shaft isn't tapped for the locking bolt, don't be afraid to drill/tap it. It's not all that difficult. I'll even lend you the drill guide if you need one.
These are carbon steel propeller shafts with a chrome/nickel finish from the seal surface on towards AFT.
If you drill and tap this shaft for the 5/16" NC internal threads, you will cut through the plating and into carbon steel.
Carbon Steel will rust up.
Yes, I've heard that about he rust, but so far, no rust for me even after after my first trip in salt water. As recommended, I use locktite on the end of the locking bolt, and then permatex#2 toward the head. I'm thinking my 'newly cut' threads are pretty well isolated from the environment..but time will tell. 'Sure gives me a lot of flexibility in prop selection, not to mention the savings in not using an OEM prop..............................
So I reread this thread from the beginning and at one point I did measure/post both the 250 and the 280 line cutter measurements.
The 250 measures .625
The 280 measures 1.375
And when I used the Solas prop with the 250 line cutter (on the 250 drive), I needed to make the 250 line cutter 1/8" shorter so the bendy tab could grab the splines.
If your propeller shaft isn't tapped for the locking bolt, don't be afraid to drill/tap it. It's not all that difficult. I'll even lend you the drill guide if you need one.
http://tinyurl.com/h5wcgor