.............. As it turns out, just yesterday, I got a timing light and checked the settings. Turns out it was 20 degrees at idle and 40 degrees at cruising rpms.
I reset the idle to 10 degrees and am going to test it out tomorrow.
Something is fishy about 20 advance at idle rpm. Most engines, when warm, will not even fire with this much spark lead. They will "buck" against this much ignition advance.
And the 40* TA @ cruise RPM is a recipe for detonation!
- Are you by chance using a digitally advancing timing light that may not be set to standard strobe mode?
- Is your harmonic balancer properly marked off for checking TA in standard strobe mode?
This would indeed appear to be odd (especially on two "like" engines) when only a carburetor change has been made..... if I understood you correctly!
One further note regarding the low rpm issue....... if ignition advance were to fall short of a correct TA, then the symptoms would be very similar to what you have described!
Example: a TA of only 20* @ 3k rpm, when the TA should actually be 28* @ 3.2k rpm (again, example only!)
You may want to pull out your OEM manual and see what is spec'd out for TA, and at what RPM.
Have you noticed lately that there seems to be an increase in the postings regarding FULL TIMING ADVANCE ? Do you think it is merely aging of distributor mechanisms or maintenance issues?
I can't asnwer that question per se', but I've spoken with many seasoned mechanics that do not give this enough consideration.
In my book, this has always been extremely important for a marine gasser!