That's great and good of you to circle back with your results - which will help others.
If you're looking to dial in a tad more top speed, check which hole the tilt pin is in.
With the over-sized previous Prop there's a good chance it's in the lowest position(closest to transom).
If it is, working your way out further may yield some very positive top speed results while maintaining the good aspects you like now.
Lowest position will yield quick planing, but somewhat bury the nose at top speed (read, speed robbing drag).
The highest position will take a little longer to plane with more bow lift, but at high speeds will eliminate a lot of nose drag and can often add 3-4+ mph.
You may find a happy medium somewhere in between.
The Amita has the quick plane great stern-lift of the 4 blade AND pretty high raked blades for bow lifting when trimmed out which may yield some great top end #'s.
My boat with power trim, runs 43mph Wot at lowest trim and 50mph trimmed up.