"For me the big question would
"For me the big question would be:
What is your maximum RPM at Wide Open Throttle with the current prop.
Generally, there are only two correct props for a particular engine/boat setup.
1) The one that let your engine run within the specified RPM range at Wide Open Throttle under normal load conditions... i.e. full tank of fuel and the usual number of folks you have on it.
2) A second prop that you MIGHT use from time to time to have your engine get to correct RPMS at WOT if you are running a heavy load, i.e. towing folks on "water toys" while having a number of folks onboard. Not a prop to use for normal day to day operation... unless of course your "normal" use is pulling folks around with boat full of people.
Still, both props are selected to meet the same criteria, i.e., that prop that allows the engine to run within the normal RPM range @ WOT "under normal load".
If you need a new prop because your current one is damaged beyond repair, but the current prop met criteria #1, just get another one of what you have."