"[b]Quote: "but spark adv
"
Quote: "but spark advance on a boat engine isn't that critical compared to automotive applications. Why? The motor is either in trolling mode--minimal advance--or on plane--full advance. Unlike a car/ truck, there's little going on in between those two rpm ranges."
I'm going to be blatant about this and with no apology being offered...... (other than to say Fastjeff, I don't like to lock horns with any good man)
So, please.... no offense what-so-ever, although you may find that my comment may not sound very kind!
So just imagine that we're all sitting around drinking a cup of coffee and discussing this!
I absolutely and fully disagree with that statement and with posting a suggestion like this on any marine forum.
We have people who may be reading and practicing this and I think that there's an unwritten responsibility that we "techy people" be as accurate here as possible.
Now.... that being said, your statement regarding the "two" RPM ranges makes some sense..... if this were the case, I'd be much more inclined to agree!
However, there is no coast time as there is with an auto scenario. A marine engine's work load, and the dreaded "Detonation" (that can be so destructive),
will suggest that this can be most dangerous at the RPM range below the prescribed full out ignition advance RPM...... an RPM, by the way, that we may sustain for a short duration!
As you know, detonation damage can occur almost silently and in very short order.
IMO, this is why the proper curve and limit must be used.
Again Jeff, I have no dog in any fight here, much less with you...... other than to debunk misinformation as to hopefully prevent someone from undergoing detonation damage.
Quote: "I am getting full advance at 3,000 rpms (38 degrees)"
Bob, I am curious and would like to see your OEM ignition advance curve data.
38* full in by 3K rpm is very strong and early, IMO.
I'd suggest that any of us spend the few extra dollars necessary and have a shop put our distributor on a machine and set to the OEM curve and limit! Tweak some only if you know what you are doing.
And paaaaleeeeeeeeze.... not only set your BASE ignition timing, but also and always check your TAT (total advance timing) with a good ole strobe type light... non-digital advance mode!!!! (we want Real Time and in Real Degrees)
It is not difficult to do! It does require that your harmonic balancer be properly marked off!
Pass the cream and sugar, please!
."