Honda has just recently sent to dealers, copies of several different how to's for consumers. One of them is how to change a water pump in a BF75D and BF90D.
Ask your dealer for a copy. It is meant to be given to customers. An unusual move for Honda, I know.
I would post it, but have not been able to figure out how to post a pdf.
Hopefully, you bought the service kit, witch should have an impeller, o ring, gasket, and key. That is the minimum that you should change. If there is any scoring at all on the plate or the cup, inside the housing, they should be changed too.
Mike