PDA

View Full Version : Have any Towing Safety stories to share?



James Cole
09-21-2010, 10:13 AM
We've all had a "friend of a friend" in some sort of towing mishap that could have been avoided. In fact there might be one or two of us around here that are "that guy."

Who has a grizzly tale to tell? Got any tips or advice for other boaters?

makomark
09-22-2010, 03:07 PM
Here's the brief recap:

Go to pick up "new" used boat. small brand name i/o equipped, perfect for fishing. three hour drive, partner had seen the boat and executed sea trials. Boat old but reasonable condition given price. trailer is two years old and 'slightly used by previous owner.

To the marina. Find trailer in field, in fact has been used once (maybe twice) and that was two years ago. Check brakes, tires, lights and get the truck wiring working with the trailer wiring...all good (once we find an air compressor) and the trailer is towed to the marina.

The boat is on the hi & dri rack. The lift operator shows up ~ 15 minutes later, gets directions from the boss, and comes back with the boat. lowers boat to trailer and backs out. Not too bad....walk towards the back and Oh S--T!!! the transom is sitting forward of the last set of rollers by at least a foot with the bow in the stop chock.

Get the yard boss and ask WTFO? He shakes his head until he sees it and then gets redfaced. Go to the cafe and have a late breakfast and we'll have it fixed when you are done. Off to the cafe. An hour later, the transom is balanced on the end rollers. (The yard was recognized as the local volume dealer for the big name trailer the boat was sitting on and yes, they sold the trailer to the previous owner.)

Start on the trip home. The local roads are fine and the truck handles the "new" boat load a bit better than expected. The hydraulic brakes are functioning but not well behaved. We suspect drums are not round due to age and rust. On to the state road. All is fine until about 10 miles from the marina. A long downgrade followed by the rise on the other side...things felt fine until about halfway down the hill. Both of us in the truck's cab knew something was 'different' but wasn't sure what the cause was.

A few miles down the road another hill but a bit steeper. A few hundred yeards down the hill, I looked over my shoulder the the boat looked weird. the Yawing event had started and proceeded to increase as we proceeded down the hill. Looking forward was even uglier as the truck was now gyrating back and forth between both sides of this two lane road. Good thing there were no other cars on the road at that time. Somewhere around the bottom of the hill the strap holding the hull to the trailer broke and the hull climbed up on the fender. As we started up the other side, the speed was reduced and then the yawing subsided.

We came to a stop on the shoulder of the opposing lane of traffic. The chine was dragged along the asphalt at least a 1/4 mile and was much thinner than when the trip started. Fender on the trailer rubbing on the tire but no serious damage. Cars started appearing very frequently and the very helpful nature of that community's residents was obvious (yes, before cell phones were common).

Conclusion - the "idiot" in the marina that "adjusted" the trailer to fit the boat only moved the bow stop back a foot or so. Nobody, including us, checked the tongue weight (less than 100# post accident and the boat alone is over 3000#). No matter how "prominent" (or other adjective) the "dealer" is (or is rumored to be), ALWAYS do a detailed verification on a "new to you" rig before hooking the coupler over the ball....Not only your life but all the ones around you could be at stake.

DavidW2009
09-26-2010, 05:23 AM
This little, recent story has more to do with the tow vehicle than the boat/trailer.

Until a year ago, I had not had a boat in the water for 35 years. The last boat I trailered around was a relatively light 14' Silverline. Never had any problem with tow vehicle brakes.

In the past year I bought two boats, much heavier than the 14'er. The tow vehicle I'm using now is a Chevy G-20 conversion van with a 350 CID (5.7L). I've towed these two boats about ten times in the past year.

Last Friday I decided to tow the I/O boat to the lake to check the latest round of repairs. Hooked it up and headed down the driveway (1/4 mile long). I get to the road and apply the brakes and the pedal goes almost to the floor. Never had any indication of a brake problem before. The brakes front and rear were checked about 10K miles ago and found to be in very good condition with lots of wear left.

No, I'm not going to the lake today.....not until the brakes are fixed.

Turned the rig around and headed back up the driveway. Parked the boat and removed the van wheels: The brake pads on the front and shoes on the rear are SHOT. Worn almost to the rivets. The rear wheel cylinders are leaking and a self-adjuster on one side is rusted solid.

It then occured to me the cost of towing a 2600# boat. Towing is definitely hard on the tow vehicle's brakes. The rear drums get submerged when launching and that, no doubt, adds to the accelerated wear. So, the G20 got all new brakes and wheel cylinders this weekend. Brakes are back to normal or better. But it's something else I'm going to have to check every year and keep in mind when towing a boat.

Now I'm considering a brake system for the trailers, but need to do some more reading and research as to what would be best.

charlesbrian
02-22-2012, 11:27 PM
Safety should always be your main concern when you're pulling a trailer. Because no matter how easy and comfortable the process, the fact is that your towing rig weighs more and doesn't dodge or stop as easily as other cars on the road.

towing chicago (http://www.xltowingchicago.com) | chicago towing company (http://www.xltowingchicago.com)