"Jason,
I would start by turn
"Jason,
I would start by turning off both upper and lower ignitions. Disconnect the wires at the temp sender. Then take and ohmmeter and measure the resistance of the sender terminal to its own case. It should read something like 30-240 ohms. (A dual station sender will read differenctly, but it should not be open or shorted). If you get a decent reading then move the lead from the case of the sender to the engine chassis where a clean ground can be obtained. If it now reads open, there is something insulating the case of the sender from ground. If it passes this test, hook the wires back up to the sender and disconnect the lead on both upper and lower gauges that does NOT go to the ignition source. Measure the wire you just disconnected against the ground bus in tour instrument cluster. You should see the same resistance you saw on the sender + a an ohm or two for wire reistance. Now reconnect the wire back to the gauge. If you read a high resistance, you will have to find out where the wire is open. Look for corroded lugs. Repeat the same for the other station's temp gauge. If the resistance was good, turn on the ignition and measure the terminal opposite the one you just tested on the temp gauge and you should see 12-14volts DC. Again, if not present, look at the lugs and crimps. Each station should have only the sender itself in common. Hope this helps...
From the various gauge problems you describe on the lower station, it sounds like a bad connection from the ignition switch to the common side of each gauge. Usually they are "daisy chained" together such that if the first crimp on lug fails, everything "downstream" will fail to. The best way to measure this is to turn on the ignition and start with the gauge closest to the ignition switch and take measurements at each gauge. If you see any voltage drop (assuming a digital meter) that is where to look. Untinned copper wire turns black over time in a nautical environment and will build up resistance. If you make repairs, I recommend cleaning and tinning the wire first, then soldering to the lug (even if it is a crimp type lug). The same could be true for ground although most gauges are not grounded (voltmeter excepted)."